GOTHAM Season 1 Episode 13
Episode Title: âWelcome Back, Jim Gordonâ
Writer: Megan Mostyn-Brown
Director: Wendey Stanzler
Previously on âGothamâ:
Episode 1.12 What the Little Bird Told Himâ
Â
As you may have heard, âGothamâ has been renewed for a second season. But even before that happened, itâs future on Fox was assured as long as it continued to attract a sizable audience. Thatâs really what it all boils down to. The networks only care about ratings, not quality.
Last weekâs episode marked a rare uptick in âGothamâsâ quality. Against all odds, there were parts of it that were actually interesting. Can âWelcome Back, Jim Gordonâ continue that momentum? Or will âGothamâ slink back into the comfortable mediocrity that has come to define the show?
It doesnât take a Riddler to guess how this one is gonna play out.
The Mighty Butch
After being exposed and dethroned by Falcone, things werenât looking good for Fish Mooney (Jada Pinkett Smith). A Falcone family sadist named Bob was given the task of torturing Fish to get a âsincereâ apology out of her. Meanwhile, Fishâs right hand man (and currently, her only man) Butch Gilzean (Drew Powell) faced his own imminent execution.
But clearly Butch is some kind of escapist, as he pulled a Batman from the back of the truck and overpowered his captors. Then Butch singlehandedly rescued Fish and he apparently entered Bobâs lair without making any noise⌠just like the Dark Knight will frequently do a long time after this series ends. Butchâs unlikely heroics were perhaps one of the biggest WTF?! moments of the series to date.
Butch wanted to get Fish out of Gotham City, but she refused to leave until they killed The Penguin, aka Oswald Cobblepot (Robin Lord Taylor).
Wayneâs World
Did you happen to notice that âGothamâ was much better without the weak writing in every scene that features Bruce Wayne (David Mazouz)? Well, the kid is back from âSwitzerlandâ with his trusty butler/guardian, Alfred Pennyworth (Sean Pertwee). I donât even blame Mazouz for Bruceâs poor depiction. The writers on this show clearly donât know how to make their youngest cast members sound like actual children.
After another forced appearance by future villainess, Ivy Pepper (Clare Foley), Bruce finally got his wish when future Catwoman, Selina Kyle (Camren Bicondova) visited him at Stately Boring Wayne Manor. Bruce tried to give Selina tokens of his affection and convince her to live with him, but she rejected him and claimed that she didnât actually see the face of the man who shot his parents.
Dejected, Bruce sunk back into a childâs imitation of Batman, by trying to will himself into becoming a great detective.
Cop In The Hen House
Bruce may not have the skills of a Dark Knight Detective at this point in his life, but heâs coming off as a better detective than James Gordon (Ben McKenzie)⌠if only because Gordon is so clueless that heâs becoming farcical. In a sequence that was funny for all of the wrong reasons, Gordon eagerly met a man willing to testify about witnessing another manâs murder, only to take his witness back to the police station where he was promptly murdered as well.
Gordon correctly guessed that a cop was responsible for the latest murder, but both Harvey Bullock (Donal Logue) and Captain Sarah Essen (Zabryna Guevara) warned him not to pursue the case. Could it be that the asshole cop (whom weâve only seen once before), Arnold John Flass (Dash Mihok) is the man behind the murders? Well, there really arenât many other suspects, are there?
Meanwhile, Edward Nygma (Cory Michael Smith) continued his romantic pursuit of Kristen Kringle (Chelsea Spack). I find it hard to believe that the writers of âGothamâ donât realize how hacky this sublot is. When Kristen showed Edward the slightest kindness, he basically did his version of Jim Carreyâs âso⌠youâre saying that thereâs a chance!â
Tip of The Iceberg
Because Gordon canât solve the case on his own, he turns to Oswald. Hilariously, Oswald is ecstatic to see Gordon and he welcomed his âfriendâ into the nightclub formerly owned by Fish. Oswald even seemed to truly see Gordon as a friend and he put one of his men on Gordonâs case. The thug quickly got to the bottom of the case by torturing a copâs wife before he literally dropped the evidence on Gordon.
But Oswald celebrated his victory a little too soon. Fish and Butch showed up at the club to kill him. However, Oswaldâs luck held out as he was saved by the timely arrival of Victor Zsasz (Anthony Carrigan) and his small army of wannabe Grace Jones lookalikes. Butch managed to kill one of the henchwomen before he secured Fishâs escape and he stayed behind to cover her exit. Of course, Oswald emerged largely unscathed by the whole thing.
Harvey Goes Fishing
The last friend that Fish has in Gotham turned out to be Harvey Bullock. Harvey even showed some romantic interest in Fish as he advised her to get out of town before planting a kiss on her. Fish insisted that she wouldnât leave Gotham for long, but she asked Harvey to find and help Butch if he is still alive.
Earlier at the precinct, Gordon confronted Flass with the evidence supplied by Oswaldâs mob connection. Gordon the self-righteous then shamed his fellow cops until enough of them supported his power play to make Flass pay for his crimes.
Gordonâs Lament
However, that smug look on Gordonâs face didnât last long. Outside of the precinct, Gordon was accosted by the police detective whose wife was tortured to get the info for his case. Gordon looked on in horror as he realized that he compromised himself to Oswald, and innocent people were hurt despite his intentions.
I have no faith in âGothamâ to really examine Gordonâs realization that he engineered the events that led to the torture of a woman. All in the name of justice. But that kind of duality is far too complex for âGotham,â which will probably dump that subplot halfway through the next episode.
I wish the writers on this show treated âGothamâ like an actual noir story. Watching Gordon suffer such a personal failure could have been a really powerful moment. The way that the scene was filmed also suggested that the creative team on this show thought that they had delivered a dramatic ending. But the tone of the scene was too heavy handed and over-the-top.
Much like âGothamâ itself.
